Grab your salt and burn those feelings, folks, because we're about to wade into the most controversial love story this side of Heaven: Did Castiel, everyone's favorite angel with a trench coat fetish, actually confess his undying love for Dean Winchester?

The "Supernatural" finale, much like a vengeful spirit, continues to haunt fans even years later. And at the heart of the drama? Castiel's final, earth-shattering declaration: "I love you.
" Cue the fandom exploding like a holy water balloon in a demon's face.
Deathbed Declaration or Buddy-Buddy Love? Unpacking the Controversy
Here's the scene: Castiel, facing down Billie (Death, but with better hair), decides to make the ultimate sacrifice. Remember that deal he made with the Shadow? It comes to collect on its promise, but only when Castiel experiences "true happiness." Enter his confession to Dean, a moment so emotionally charged it would make Cupid reach for his angel blade.
"Finally!" cried half the fandom, who had been busy spotting longing looks and shared burgers as evidence of Destiel (Dean/Castiel) for years.

"Wait, what?!" cried the other half, who felt blindsided by the sudden declaration.
The article is not finished. Click on the next page to continue.
The article is not finished. Click on the next page to continue.
Next page